Brooke White
I Am, I Said
I feel like we haven't heard a Brooke White song in weeks. A song she took and fit to her country-inflected singer-songwriter style without seeming lost in someone else's arrangement. This was Brooke being Brooke, before we completely forgot who she was. If she were doing this more consistently as she had for a while early in the finals. She'd be contending for the final two.
— by James Poniewozik
| White's first song: I'm a Believer |